St. John · US Virgin Islands
Homemade Ice Cream & Old-Fashioned Milkshakes
We make our ice cream right here on the hill. Come on up for the sunset, stay for dessert.
Made fresh in house
Ice Cream – $8
We churn it here at the bar. Four flavors, all day, until the kitchen closes at 8.
Vanilla · Chocolate · Strawberry · Mango Sorbet
Make it grown up.
Add a shot of tequila, peanut butter or coffee, or a Painkiller with or without the rum.
Blended the old way
Old-Fashioned Milkshakes – $11
Same house-made ice cream, thick and cold and worth the drive up the hill. New on the menu and going fast.
Vanilla · Chocolate · Strawberry
16oz Silicone Souvenir Cup – $18
Take it home, bring it back. Free ounce with every refill.
Common Questions
Where can I get ice cream on St. John?
The Windmill Bar makes its ice cream in house and serves it every day from 11AM to 8PM, up at Susannaberg on St. John. Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, and mango sorbet, $8 a serving.
Do you make your own ice cream?
We do. It is made fresh in house at the bar, not shipped in.
Do you have milkshakes?
Yes. Old-fashioned milkshakes in vanilla, chocolate, or strawberry for $11, blended from the same house-made ice cream.
Can you add alcohol to the ice cream?
Yes. Add a shot of tequila, either peanut butter or coffee, or a Painkiller with or without the rum.
Is there a dairy-free option?
The mango sorbet is our dairy-free option.
What time do you serve ice cream and milkshakes?
Every day from 11AM to 8PM, the same hours as the kitchen. No reservations needed, just come on up.
Find Us Up the Hill
Open daily, 11AM to 8PM. The 1780s Susannaberg windmill behind you, the best sunset view in the Virgin Islands out front. No reservations, just show up.
17 A Estate Susannaberg, Cruz Bay, St. John, USVI 00830
(912) 657-2564